When Not to Use SLS, SLA, or DLP 3D Printing

3D printing is an incredibly versatile manufacturing method, but it’s not the right solution for every project. While Selective Laser Sintering (SLS), Stereolithography (SLA), and Digital Light Projection (DLP) offer significant advantages, there are scenarios where they might not be the best fit. Understanding these limitations can help you make informed decisions and achieve the best possible outcome for your prototypes and production parts.

When Not to Use SLS 3D Printing

SLS is known for its ability to produce strong, functional parts with complex geometries. However, it does have some drawbacks that may make it unsuitable for certain applications.

Lack of High Surface Detail

SLS parts have a slightly rough, grainy texture due to the powder-based process. If you require ultra-smooth, highly detailed surfaces straight off the machine, SLA or DLP may be better options. While vapour smoothing can improve surface quality, it won’t achieve the high-definition crispness of resin-based prints.

Not Ideal for Large, Flat Surfaces

Large, flat areas can sometimes exhibit slight warping due to the nature of the sintering process. If your design relies on extremely tight tolerances across large planes, CNC machining may offer better stability and accuracy.

Opaque Material

SLS primarily uses nylon-based materials, which are opaque (we use Matrix PA12 CR). If your project requires clear or translucent components, SLA or PolyJet printing would be more suitable.

When Not to Use SLA 3D Printing

SLA is a fantastic choice for high-detail prototypes, but it has some limitations that make it unsuitable for certain applications.

Fragility Under Stress

SLA prints are often brittle compared to SLS or CNC-machined parts. If your part needs to withstand significant mechanical stress, impact, or flexing, SLS or CNC machining may be a better alternative.

Sensitivity to UV and Moisture

Resin materials used in SLA printing can degrade over time when exposed to UV light or humidity. If your part is going to be used in outdoor or harsh environments, SLS or injection moulding may be a better choice.

Limited High-Temperature Resistance

Many SLA resins have relatively low heat deflection temperatures, which can make them unsuitable for high-temperature applications. However, we offer Matrix HT300, a specialist SLA material designed for extreme thermal environments, providing exceptional heat resistance while maintaining rigidity. If your project requires an alternative high-temperature solution, DLP with specialist high-temp resins or SLS using PA12-based materials may be a better fit, depending on the mechanical and environmental demands of your part.

When Not to Use DLP 3D Printing

DLP shares many similarities with SLA but differs in its method of curing resin layer by layer with a digital light projector. While it offers high accuracy, there are cases where it may not be the right choice.

Part Size Limitations

It can be challenging to produce large parts in a single print because of machine sizes. If your design exceeds the size constraints (our DLP printer has a build envelope of 124.8 x 70.2 x 196 mm (XYZ)), SLS or CNC machining may be more suitable.

Challenges with Non-Conformal Wall Thicknesses

DLP printing works best with consistent wall thicknesses. If your design features sudden changes in thickness or non-uniform walls, you may encounter issues such as internal stresses or distortion during printing. In such cases, SLS or vacuum casting might be better suited to achieve a more reliable result.

Surface Finish Not Always Perfect

DLP produces high-detail parts, but some resins can exhibit layer lines or surface inconsistencies, especially on curved surfaces. Additional finishing processes may be required if aesthetics are critical.

Making the Right Choice for Your Project

We believe in helping our customers find the best manufacturing method for their needs, even if that means advising against 3D printing. If your part demands extreme strength, tight tolerances, or specialist materials, CNC machining or vacuum casting might be better options.

However, when 3D printing is the right choice, we offer an instant quoting platform, Matrix, to help you quickly assess costs and lead times.

Whether you choose SLS, SLA, or DLP, our team is here to ensure you get the best possible results for your prototypes and end-use parts.

Not sure which process is right for you? Get in touch with our experts today.

Talk to us

Contact us on 01763 249760 to discuss your requirements.

Ready to get started? Get an instant quote for SLS, SLA and DLP 3D printed parts using Matrix. For all other requirements, please click here to request a quote.